This guest article is penned by South African attorney and academic Nathan-Ross Adams, a leading authority in AI, IT, and cyber law within the MENA region. Nathan is a celebrated figure in the legal space for his expertise, and regularly collaborates with some of the world’s most prominent technology giants—some of whom are also his esteemed clients.
In 2024, Nathan launched his own practice, ITLawCo, offering specialised services at the cutting edge of technology, data, AI, and the law.
In the commercial world, we’ve traded everything from spices to stocks, but the 21st century has introduced a new currency: data. In this burgeoning data economy, data purchase agreements (DPAs) are the unsung heroes, quietly ensuring data flows smoothly, legally, and profitably between parties. But here’s the catch—data isn’t just any commodity. It’s intangible, often personal, and comes with a tangled web of ownership and regulatory strings attached.
In this article, we’ll unravel the mysteries of DPAs, exploring their components, intellectual property (IP) considerations, and why drafting one is both an art and a science. Along the way, we’ll add some real-world flavour and a dash of humour—because legal frameworks don’t have to be dull.
What are Data Purchase Agreements?
Picture a DPA as the meticulous party planner for a data transaction. It sets the rules for how data is sold, delivered, used, and protected, ensuring that everyone has a good time (legally speaking) and no one wakes up to a compliance hangover. These agreements are vital whether you’re buying anonymised user behaviour data for marketing or detailed geospatial datasets for real estate development.
Key Ingredients of a Data Purchase Agreement
The key components of a DPA include:
Data description: Specifies what exactly is being bought.
Ownership and licensing: Determines the rights acquired by the buyer.
Usage restrictions: Outlines acceptable uses and prohibits misuse.
Compliance: Ensures adherence to regulatory standards.
Liability and indemnity: Allocates risks like inaccuracies or breaches.
Termination and dispute resolution: Provides mechanisms for when things go south.
The Intellectual Property 'Elephant in the Room'
Intellectual property (IP) considerations often complicate data transactions. While raw data itself isn’t inherently protected under copyright law, certain datasets can fall under IP protections, such as:
Database rights: Databases showing significant effort in organisation may be protected.
Trade secrets: Proprietary datasets that give a company a competitive edge may qualify as trade secrets.
Copyright: Specific data presentations, like artistic visualisations, may qualify for copyright protection.
IP clauses matter because they protect buyers from inadvertently stepping into legal cobwebs. Imagine buying a dataset for AI training only to find it includes third-party content with unlicensed IP—this could lead to costly lawsuits. DPAs must confirm the seller’s right to sell the data, specify the buyer’s acquired rights, and include indemnities for IP claims.
A common issue is the creation of derivative works or resale of insights. For instance, if a financial institution uses purchased data to build a credit scoring algorithm, does the seller have rights to that derivative work? Clear language is essential to avoid disputes.
Real-World Applications of Data Purchase Agreements
DPAs are versatile and widely used across industries. Here are some practical examples:
AI training
Startups buy anonymised social media data to train AI models. DPAs often include clauses restricting unethical uses, such as creating deepfakes, while ensuring buyers own AI model outputs.
Marketing insights
Retailers purchasing consumer data for marketing require quality guarantees and IP assurances that the data isn’t plagiarised.
Pharmaceutical companies acquiring anonymised medical data for research include clauses to comply with GDPR and ensure ethical use, such as obtaining patient consent.
Real estate developers buying geospatial data negotiate exclusivity within a region and demand indemnities against third-party claims.
Common Pitfalls in Data Purchase Agreements
DPAs aren’t without their challenges. Here are some common pitfalls:
Ambiguity: Unclear terms around derivative works or sublicensing can lead to disputes.
Regulatory blind spots: Cross-border transactions that overlook compliance with local laws risk hefty fines.
Data integrity risks: Inaccurate or incomplete data reduces value.
A cautionary tale involves a company purchasing “anonymised” healthcare data, only to discover it could be re-identified, resulting in legal troubles and reputational damage. The lesson? Always conduct due diligence.
Best Practices for Drafting Data Purchase Agreements
To create robust DPAs, consider the following:
Understand the data: Know exactly what you’re buying and its potential IP issues.
Ensure compliance: Tailor the agreement to meet global and local data protection laws.
Engage experts: Work with legal and IP specialists who understand data nuances.
Incorporate cybersecurity measures: Protect data during transfer and storage.
The Future of Data Purchase Agreements
The future of DPAs is poised for innovation. Blockchain technology could enable real-time verification of data provenance, reducing disputes. Meanwhile, AI-driven contracts might automatically flag potential compliance or IP issues, making data transactions smarter and safer.
Closing Thoughts
Data purchase agreements might not seem glamorous, but they are the foundation of the data economy. By balancing legal safeguards with commercial pragmatism, DPAs enable businesses to innovate responsibly. Whether you’re buying data for AI, marketing, or urban planning, a robust DPA ensures you stay ahead of the game while avoiding costly pitfalls. In the world of data, a well-drafted agreement isn’t just paperwork—it’s peace of mind.
Stay connected with Nathan and ITLawCo by clicking the links below:
Nathan-Ross Adams:
ITLawCo:
Thank you for sharing your expertise with us, Nathan and ITLawCo!
This information was last updated on 5 December 2024. This information is for general educational and entertainment purposes and is subject to change at any time.
Comments